What is a good way
to train my dog?
The
goal of training is to teach
the pet to respond to a variety
of commands. To be successful,
the owner must first be able
to get the pet to exhibit the
desired response when the command
is given. To achieve this, the
owner can use a lure such as
a food or toy (lure-reward training)
or a closed hand target (target
training) to encourage or lead
the dog to the correct response.
Alternately, training devices
such as a head halter and leash
can be used to prompt the dog
into the response. The dog should
then be rewarded. Although primary
reinforcers such as food or
a favored toy are generally
used first, over time secondary
reinforcers (e.g. clicker, praise)
should intermittently replace
these. Clicker training pairs
a clicker with food so that
the clicker soon becomes a consistent
predictor of food. It can then
be used to immediately mark
and reward desired responses.
Over time the
training can then progress to
gradually more complex or more
accurate responses (shaping).
If you are interested in clicker
training see an obedience instructor
or check www.clickertraining.com
on the web.
What
about punishing the incorrect
behavior so the dog learns to
do the right thing?
Unfortunately,
many trainers still advocate
punishment, which is intended
to discourage or "reduce"
undesirable behavior rather
than train and encourage desirable
behavior. This is not really
training because punishment
does not teach the dog what
it is "supposed"
to do. Punishment can also cause
fear, anxiety, increased aggression
and discomfort or harm to the
pet. Some dogs may even retaliate
or defend themselves by attacking
the person who is administering
the punishment. Therefore, it
is not a logical, scientifically
sound, or acceptable method
of training and may in fact
be counterproductive.
What
is perhaps confusing is that
many dogs have been successfully
trained with punishment. In
fact, many of these dogs are
actually trained with negative
reinforcement where the pain
or discomfort is released as
soon as the desired behavior
is exhibited. This is a difficult
concept to teach and requires
"impeccable" timing.
In addition, dogs that have
been trained with punishment
may be fearful of misbehaving
in the trainer's presence.
Some of these dogs are then
labeled as "one-man-dogs"
because the dog is only responsive
to a trainer who can successfully
administer the punishment. On
the other hand, dogs trained
with rewards and shaping should
respond to the commands of any
family member as long as the
commands are consistent and
positive.
What types of training
devices are available?
There
are a wide variety of leash,
halter, and harness systems
that can be used for walking
and training. In fact, a control
device attached to either the
head, neck or body is essential
when leash control is mandatory,
as well as for those dogs that
do not heel or come consistently
on verbal command.
Choke,
pinch and prong collars have
been designed to control and
train in a manner that makes
it increasingly uncomfortable
if the dog does not obey. The
more forceful the owner's
pull, the more discomfort for
the pet. Choke collar training
may be useful as a means of
applying negative reinforcement.
This can be accomplished by
issuing a command, pulling on
the choke collar to get the
desired response and then immediately
releasing as soon as the dog
complies (obeys). In other words
release from discomfort indicates
to the dog that the desired
response is now being exhibited.
Unfortunately, since many owners
are unskilled, untrained or
unsuccessful in the use of negative
reinforcement, the choke, pinch,
and prong collars are primarily
used to correct or punish undesirable
behavior. In the short run,
these corrections may cause
sufficient discomfort for the
behavior to cease. However,
with repeated exposure and training,
the dog's fear and anxiety
may actually increase each time
it is exposed to the stimulus
(because previous exposures
have been uncomfortable or aversive).
Conversely, some dogs may become
so accustomed (desensitized)
to the effects of the choke
or pinch device that it becomes
ineffective. Although many trainers
still train with devices that
are intended to pull, jerk,
choke, punish or "correct",
the most effective and humane
means of training is through
motivation, positive reinforcement
and shaping.
Body
harnesses or head halter restraint
are two alternatives to neck
collars. Some body harnesses
merely serve as restraint devices
while others such as the K9
Pull Control™, Lupi™
and No Pull Halter™ have
been specially designed to stop
pulling since they pull the
forelegs back when the dog attempts
to lunge forward. However these
devices do little to aid in
training or control. There are
also a number of devices that
utilize head control. Since
the Gentle Leader™ (also
known as the Promise System™)
has both a neck and nose strap
adjustment, it can be used either
to control the dog when the
owner is holding the leash,
or with a leash or "drag"
line left attached and dangling,
for immediate "remote"
control. Therefore it might
also be referred to as a head
collar. The Halti™ is
a head halter, which is an effective
leash control device but cannot
be fitted to leave attached
to the dog. The Snoot Loop™
is a head halter with side adjustments
to allow for a snugger muzzle
fit, thereby reducing the chances
that the pet can remove it.
Other products such as the NewTrix™
head halter are designed to
stop pulling but do not aid
in training or control.
How
might I use a head collar/halter
for control?
One
of the most effective means
of gaining control, and ensuring
that the pet responds quickly
to each command is to use a
leash and head halter such as
the Gentle Leader™ for
training. With the Gentle Leader™,
the owner gains control naturally
through pressure exerted behind
the neck and around the muzzle.
The head halter acts as a tool
to help achieve the desired
response without punishment
and to communicate the owner's
intentions. The proponents of
head halters point to the fact
that horses can be successfully
and humanely controlled with
head devices since "where
the nose goes the body follows".
Yet dog owners continue to try
and control dogs with neck restraint
(often with limited success).
With a head halter the owner
can gain eye contact and reorient
the dog to perform the desirable
response (sort of a power steering
option for dogs). With the head
halter properly fitted and the
leash slack, the dog is not
restricted from panting, eating,
drinking, chewing, barking,
jumping up, biting, lunging
forward, or stealing from the
table or the garbage. On the
other hand, since the halter
encircles the head and muzzle,
a pull on the leash can immediately
curtail pulling, barking, chewing,
stealing, stool eating and even
some forms of aggression. The
head halter and remote leash
can also be used to prompt the
dog to respond to a command
(e.g. "Quiet" for
barking or "Off"
for puppy nipping). A release
indicates to the dog that it
is performing the desired behavior.
With a 10-foot leash attached
the head halter also provides
the owner with a mechanism for
interrupting and deterring undesirable
behavior immediately (e.g. garbage
raiding, jumping up, house-soiling. A longer rope can be used for
outdoor training.
How
exactly does the head collar
work?
Pets
tend to oppose or pull against
pressure. Dogs that walk or
lunge ahead of their owners
are therefore more likely to
pull even harder if the owner
pulls back on the leash. There
are three basic ways of pulling
on the head halter to achieve
most goals. If the dog is walking
at the owners side or slightly
behind the owner with a minimum
of slack on the leash, all the
owner has to do is pull forward
to get the dog to back up (heel,
follow). A pull upward will
close the mouth (barking, nipping)
while continuing to pull up
and forward will back the dog
into a sit. Of course, with
the leash attached to the head
halter, the owner can immediately
turn the head to achieve eye
contact. A continuous pull rather
than a tug or jerk should be
used until the desired behavior
is achieved. The second hand
can also be used to gently guide
the head into position. Immediately
releasing tension then indicates
to the dog that it is now responding
acceptably.
Training
should begin in calm environments
with minimal distractions. The
dog is given the command and
if it responds appropriately,
a favored treat can be given
as a reward. A lure reward or
closed hand target can be used
to help guide the pet into the
correct response. After a few
successful responses the treat
can be phased out and given
intermittently but the praise
and stroking should continue.
Clicker training (as discussed)
would be another option. If
the command is given and the
desired response cannot be achieved,
an immediate pull on the head
halter can be used to ensure
success. The tension is then
released and the dog rewarded.
What
are the most important elements
to be successful with a head collar?
There
are five key elements to successful
head halter training.
- Fit:
The neck strap should be high
and snug, and the nose strap
adjusted so it can't
be pulled over the end of
the nose. Use rewards and
distractions to help the dog
to adapt quickly. The dog
can then be taken for a walk
or played with to keep it
distracted while getting used
to the head device.
- Be
prepared: Keep a short amount
of slack on the leash (less
than 3 cm/ 1 inch) and be
prepared to immediately pull
the dog into position if it
does not respond to a command.
A gentle pull (not jerk) up
and forward can get eye contact
(for target training, control
and calming), close the mouth,
and get the dog to back up
into a heel or sit. Using
the second hand to guide or
support the head can help
the dog to respond faster
and calm quicker.
- Motivate:
Remember the goal is to encourage
the dog to respond to the
command. An appealing tone
of voice, positive eye contact,
target training, primary reinforcers
such as special treats and
toys, and secondary reinforcers
such as praise, clickers and
stroking can be used to improve
success. The rewards (stroking,
clicker, food, toy) should
not be given until the dog
responds appropriately.
- Release:
Release immediately as soon
as the desired response is
exhibited
-
Reward or repeat: As soon
as you begin to release the
tension (a very small amount
of slack), be prepared to
reward or repeat. If the dog
remains in a position with
some slack in the line, give
rewards. If the dog does not
maintain an acceptable position
on the slackened leash, take
up the slack by pulling once
again to obtain the desired
response. Release and either
reward the desirable response
or repeat the pull and release
until the acceptable response
is achieved.
Once
these steps are accomplished,
the owner can proceed to more
complex tasks or more difficult
environments. For example, the
dog can be taught to ‘sit'
and ‘stay' for gradually
longer periods of time before
the reward is given. The owner
can gradually move farther from
the dog [still maintaining only
a few centimeters (1 inch) of
slack] to train the dog to stay
and not to follow or lunge forward.
And, once the dog will walk
by the owner's side, the
‘heel' or ‘follow'
can be practiced at times when
the dog might lunge forward
on a walk or jump up at visitors
at the door or bark.
|